Skip to content Skip to footer

LIBE Committee warned of a deepening crisis of transparency, accountability and institutional independence in Malta

Momentum Leader Arnold Cassola and Committee member Natasha Azzopardi presented eight major concerns to the European Parliament’s Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs (LIBE) during their visit to Malta on 16 November 2026.

The presentation highlighted a worrying pattern of declining transparency, weakened institutional independence and a lack of accountability, which is eroding citizens’ trust in public institutions.

Among the main concerns raised were:

  1. Concealed public documents: A 300-page report commissioned by Joseph Muscat in 2017 on the impact of overpopulation on Malta’s infrastructure remains unpublished. Momentum insists that this report belongs to the Maltese people and must be made public.
  2. Failed prosecutions: Repeated procedural and evidential mistakes have led to the collapse of cases involving prominent businessmen, raising serious questions about the effectiveness and consistency of criminal prosecutions.
  3. Ignored FOI requests: This is becoming the norm with a number of authorities.  As an example, Momentum provided the LIBE Committee with a recent case whereby The Malta Tourism Authority has failed to respond to an FOI request concerning VisitMalta’s estimated 150,000 euro sponsorship of Italian Sixth Division football club Ars et Labor Ferrara, owned by developer Joseph Portelli, despite 77 days having passed.
  4. Institutional capture: Momentum questioned the independence of the Police Commissioner and Attorney General, highlighting concerns over investigations involving politically connected individuals and calling for greater transparency in magisterial inquiries. Magisterial Inquiries should be published by default and only kept unpublished in special exceptional cases.
  5. Questions over the IDPC: An unsatisfactory and unclear response from the Information and Data Protection Commissioner to an FOI complaint has raised concerns about the Office’s effectiveness in protecting citizens’ rights.
  6. Reduced transparency over ministers’ assets: Momentum condemned the abolition of ministers’ annual declarations of assets amid repeated controversies involving conflicts of interest and political connections with business interests.
  7. A weak parliamentary Opposition: Momentum criticised the PN for failing to consistently challenge powerful developers and business interests, particularly over the alleged misuse of public land and coastline.
  8. Lack of accountability in European investigations: Momentum highlighted the lack of progress and transparency surrounding the EPPO investigation into the Marsa Junction project and the delayed National Audit Office investigation.

Prof. Arnold Cassola, leader of Momentum, stressed, “These problems have a cumulative effect on Maltese democracy. When citizens see information withheld, investigations stalled, prosecutions collapsing, and oversight institutions weakened, they increasingly lose faith in the possibility of obtaining justice.”

“This growing sense of helplessness is dangerous. Citizens must be able to trust that institutions exist to protect them, regardless of the political or financial influence of those involved.”

Natasha Azzopardi called for genuinely independent institutions, transparency in public administration and equal accountability before the law. “Public institutions belong to the people. They must serve the public interest, not protect those in power.”

There is hope, you can help!

Join Momentum and build a better Malta. Volunteer, donate, or subscribe today!

What's your reaction?
0Smile0Lol0Wow0Love0Sad0Angry